The Fall Campaign (part 2)

So much has been done in the last several months. From bare benchwork to an operating switching district, this portion of the layout has been the focus of my modeling time for a while now, and it’s coming to a good place.

A street grid has been laid out. The front edge of the benchwork along the aisle is The Embarcadero, and the streets running away from the camera are Drumm and Front, ranging from Pacific to Greenwich. All more or less just to the east of and below Telegraph Hill.

This panoramic shot shows all of the ties laid down, now that I’ve got that underlying painted street grid. Switch templates are glued down to the homasote, then ties glued atop that template, and then long strips of ties connecting them all. These long tracks extending several blocks back are definitely the longest stretches of “straight track” on the whole railroad.

Note the building mockups in place for much of this. I built these to get a feel for sight lines, and how far people can reach around or between them (not very!). Simple cardboard rectangles with a roof glued on top – nothing fancy, but differing height and vaguely differing roof lines. I could make several of these a night, and without a doubt that was time well spent. Further south, towards Market St, these buildings get pretty tall (it is downtown, after all) and provide a nice separation between this Produce District and the “South of Market” area (that is yet to be built).

Many, many switches were built. It’s around 23, with several being crossovers. One or two a night for a couple of weeks, and then time to prepare them for installation. Proper cleaning, and then soldering drop leads. Every frog gets a wire, then a minimum of two wires (one for each “primary” rail, and on crossovers even more). “Bay Side is BLUE” is the mnemonic (track power bus wires are blue and white).

Then it’s time to lay all of the rail. Starting at the tracks along the aisle, I finished up the curves from the other portion of the layout, and then did each of the three “main” lines. Once those were all complete, down to Market St, it was time to extend the spurs inland. Many spikes were inserted (more than a few making the ultimate sacrifice — I’ve done a lot of hand laid track by now, and I don’t think I’d call myself good at it yet). Lots of gauge checking.

Then it’s time to install switch machines. Lots of them. This is why I lowered the L-girder: to make short order of this for those turnouts that are right above the girder (and that’s several of them). Alas, I appear to have not taken any pictures of the spaces with the Tortoises before the wiring began.

Once those were installed, it was time to put up the fascia. 1/4″ MDF, 12″ high and then cut to length. Holes drilled for the switch controls and “main” tracks indicated with tape. In other portions of the railroad, all of the other switches for spurs were able to have the same tape treatment, but that didn’t work on this section due to the sheer amount (and length) of those tracks heading away from the mains. This led me to just label each button and hope that crews can figure it out. Every switch control is straight out from the points of the associated switch. There are three groups of tracks here (Drumm St. Industries, Drumm St Yard and the Produce Yard). Each label has the grouping name (e.g., Produce Yard), and then some indication for what each of Normal and Reverse would be (e.g., Track 3 or Lead).

Oh, and all of the streets that cross the mains get street signs, using a very nice replica font for this (Fog City Gothic). Since town names don’t really do anyone any good (it’s all San Francisco), I had to find something with finer granularity to help locate things.

Then many evenings under the layout putting it all into operating shape as far as the electrons go. Power to each Tortoise control board, wires to the pushbuttons that are the operator control for each switch (latching on-off pushbuttons with built in LEDs), frog wires to the same control board which uses the Tortoise contacts to properly switch between blue & white track power feeds, and then additional track power drops.

I am a big fan of the suitcase connectors (3M 905 for 14ga to 20ga connections, and Corning UB2A for connecting the 24ga drops to a 20ga local bus extension). And please do get the correct crimping tool, especially for the UB2A. I’ve done many of them using a regular channel lock pliers, and they’re *SO* much easier to do with the right tool.

I could then move the quick-n-dirty staging tracks to south of Market, representing the SP King Street interchange and the various State Belt industries that will be in this area. Right now, it’s just two tracks (commercial turnouts & flex track, since it gets moved from time to time).

It was time then to dig out some more freight cars from storage (many of these had not seen the light of day since 2012 and the dismantling of the St. Paul Bridge & Terminal). Quick checks of wheel gauge and coupler height were performed (with only a couple of fixes needed). The road name mix is a bit off of what I would expect to see, but that can be remedied over time (for example, there are more NP reefers in my fleet than I would expect to see in SF).

Then it was time for a break-in run of the new Produce District. On January 20, 2025, an illustrious (notorious?) crew came and ran for a couple of hours, moving some cars around per their B-7 instructions. A couple of small issues were identified, but no major concerns were found and I think they had a good time.

The Fall Campaign (part 1)

Tracklaying to me feels like a military campaign — an awful lot of stuff has to be planned out so that it all comes together in the end. There’s no single session to get it done in — it can be weeks (even months) before a significant portion of the new track work is done and ready to operate.

The next section to work on will be the Produce District. This is still in the northern portion of the railroad (where the dividing line is the Ferry Building at the foot of Market Street). Much of this is the section shown in this fantastic picture. This is just around the corner on my layout (I know, I really should come up with a drawing/diagram of how all of this fits into the basement), and is to be operated from an aisle opposite the aisle for the existing area (North Point & Pier 29). This means that there’s much more room on the benchwork for the industries, warehouse, and tracks inland from The Embarcadero, and no room for the piers.

So what makes this a campaign?

Well, given the lack of AC in the basement, I don’t like to lay track in the summer (or even until after the mid-fall change to much dryer air). But that doesn’t mean that I can’t do anything.

First, I knew that the long L-girder along the wall side of the peninsula where the next district will be was right above where the main tracks will be, the ones running alongside The Embarcadero. There was insufficient room for the Tortoise switch machines that I like to use. And even switching to some lower profile switch motor would have been difficult given the lack of clearance to move around in.

I didn’t have enough support readily at hand to hold up the entire side of the layout (about 26′ long) to lower the existing girder. So I made a new girder, installed it below the existing piece, and then built up new risers to support each of the cross members, and then removed the original girder. I’ve known for years that I needed to do this, and it always felt like a major undertaking. Yet, from start to finish was no more than a week’s worth of evenings.

Here’s the new girder in place (the old one is on the floor). Now there’s much more room to install the switch machines. The end-most couple of feet of the old girder remained, for clearance of a bookshelf at the very end and because that last bit won’t need the turnouts right up front, as this is where the King Street SP interchange tracks will be.

Then came time to tackle the cabling mess. I’ve been accumulating all sorts of layout electronics over the years, and they’ve been on top of the benchwork for easy access. So the various cables all dangled over the edge of the layout. There are three DCC command stations in there (Digitrax DCS100, Pi-Sprog, and DCC-EX), two Raspberry Pi’s for various things, mostly JMRI interfaces to said command stations, main and programming track connectors (all using the Anderson PowerPole interfaces made popular by the FreeMo folks).

So I built a shelf under the layout (it was easily accessible now because I had to move things around to add all of the new cross-member risers from the new L-girder) and put all of the electronics bits underneath. In all of the re-arrangement I switched my primary control system to the DCC-EX based command station. Programming is done with the Pi-Sprog. The Digitrax system is kept around for backup purposes and for testing & comparison purposes. I can switch the State Belt between any of these three systems in about 5 minutes, half of which will be restarting JMRI with the proper interface selected.

With a hole drilled through the sub-roadbed for the programming track connection, all of the cabling is now below grade and the railroad now looks much cleaner. That last cable hanging down is just because I haven’t cleaned up that section of the benchwork yet. But look at all of the crap on the benchwork. Okay, that’s got to go now too. Time to pick things up. Alas, no picture exists of clean benchwork.

Next, I’ve been laying out a street grid, and building some (semi) temporary1 building mockups to represent some notion of what the urban infrastructure here looks like, at least in the things that concern the operations. What will the view lines be across the tracks to the buildings beyond? What level of compression still manages to look right? How reachable will things be?

So this picture represents a vague idea of what the new section will look like. Several team tracks in the middle, spanning multiple blocks each. “Traditional” street trackage alongside the adjoining row of buildings, and some more spurs heading inland on the right hand side (and off the edge of the photo).

So what else do I need to do before I can get started?

Check with the Quartermaster, since every campaign will succeed or fail on the logistics. Whoops, my coffee can of ties is nearly empty. Whoops, my stash of rail is low. Gotta replenish those before I can start in earnest.

And I haven’t even touched a bit of track yet.

More to come soon.

  1. The U of Minnesota built a bunch of “Temporary” buildings in the influx of students just after World War 2. The last one was finally taken down a couple of years AFTER I started in the mid 1980’s. “Temporary North of Appleby”: you will not be missed. ↩︎

Long time since an update

Back in 2017, after the last Minn-Rail op session of the weekend, I took time away from the layout in order to design & build a proper Wi-Fi throttle. That project lasted until earlier this year.

I’ve since returned to working on the railroad itself. Starting with a general cleanup (as flat surfaces tend to accumulate stuff), and then I embarked on a track laying campaign.

Laying track over the summertime here in my basement isn’t a good idea — it’s not terribly well humidity controlled, and I get some significant expansion/contraction cycles. The inner track really buckled badly – I get that prototypes sometimes have bad track, but this was ridiculous. So that had to be pulled up and replaced.

Next I started working on the pier tracks, which really are the entire reason the railroad exists. Simple logistics dictate that I can’t have as many as I’d like, nor can they hold as many cars as I’d like, but I can fit in 9 pier tracks, each holding two car spots. I think that’s enough to get a good feel for what their operational interest is.

This entailed finally building the 3rd track along the Embarcadero, and setting up all of the switches to cross the street and then head into a pier bulkhead. Those bulkheads are THE defining visual characteristic of the San Francisco waterfront. All of the piers north of the Ferry Building shared a common appearance, although some have been modified and modernized over the years.

This was the result of a couple of hours searching for a good picture of a pier bulkhead, figuring out the proper scale, and then printing out a copy. I’m pretty happy with the general sizing & appearance, and now I need to edit in the proper pier numbers (21 through 33) and build up a more complete structure instead just the simple building front.

The rightmost (rearmost) track is the one that’s mostly new. There’s now an additional runaround track for the North job. At the far end of this picture is the set of curved tracks pictured above, now much less wonky and having stayed that way through several seasonal changes. Those two tracks head over to Pier 43, where the car floats from the Santa Fe and Western Pacific dock. The ATSF float also services the Northwestern Pacific float dock in Tiburon.

The three mainline tracks in the foreground of this photo will curve around towards the left, and head to the South end of the railroad, terminating at a set of tracks at King Street, where the Southern Pacific leaves us a bunch of cars, and we can drop our interchange cars for the SP as well.

I’ll update soon with some pictures after the construction was completed.

Many small things happening

I’ve been doing a bunch of things, trying to get ready for the “public” debut of the State Belt this October.   I plan to host several sessions around the Minn-Rail timeframe, some as official scheduled ops and others as can be fit in to suit the schedules of the out of town guests.

To that end, I’ve been trying to do a bunch of smallish things to make the layout more friendly towards guests.   Every cross street is labeled (Stockton, Bay) with more or less accurate San Francisco style street signage.   Each industry gets a label on the spur on the fascia (since the industries themselves don’t have much in the way of signage yet, see Stauffer Chemical  or Simmons Co).

Each turnout button is more or less directly out from the points, making it fairly easy to match the arrangement on the fascia to the trackwork on the layout.   The track lines are (for now) artist’s tape of various widths.   Someday, I hope to paint on more durable artwork, but this will certainly do for now.   This is probably what you’ll see for the next several years.

 

I’ve also been working on the pavement along North Point.   Running tracks in the street are to be buried in pavement, but the spurs where cars can be spotted are laid in with cobblestones.   This is DAS air drying clay, with the cobble stones rolled in using some nifty tools.    This still needs some work, since there’s a little too much sinkage at the ties.   I’ll write more on this as I get it all figured out.

The bulk of the recent tracklaying work is done, with an overview shot here prior to cleanup.   Every tool seen here has been used within the last couple of weeks.   For the next op sessions, instead of a couple of pieces of flextrack serving as the car float interchange, the crew will be able to make their way over here to North Yard and make a block swap.    Eventually, the wharf job crew will be responsible for the car float that will be over here as well.

Below table work needs to be done here yet.  This include switch machine installation and track feeder connections to the DCC bus.

I’m also working on some paperwork to help a crew find things.  The first one is an Industry List, much like the prototype’s.   Look up “Musto Keenan” and you’ll find it listed as “535 North Point / Taylor”.   Now that the street signs are on the fascia, it should be easier to find places.    I’ll expand the overview map as well.

My goal is to have everything that I like to see when I come to a layout for the first time.   Easily readable paperwork that makes it clear what work needs to be done (handled via the B-7’s).   Maps showing where things are.  Signs for every industry.   Signs for major locations.

Other goals to make it nice for the crews include:

  • declutter the active portion of the railroad, and the to-be-built-later sections as well.   The “later” sections will still have some building mockups, some switch templates down, showing some notion of what is yet to come.
  • permanent fascia on all of the parts of the railroad we’ll be operating.   I think this makes things look cleaner
  • skirting hanging from the fascia, mostly to hide all of the clutter that used to be on top of the layout and which got moved down below
  • a central place for snacks & such.   Not right in the middle of things, but easy enough to get as needed.

Gandydancing, again

I’ve not been doing much on my own railroad for a while, as I spent a number of weekend work sessions helping to build the benchwork for a layout for a young gentleman (to support the Wishes and More Foundation). That benchwork has been finished, so I’ve been back to my own railroad.

The next section to be built is the area up near Fisherman’s Wharf. This includes Pier 43 (the car float connection to the AT&SF, WP and NWP), North Yard, and a small handful of industry locations (Standard Oil, Del Monte, Cincotta Bros), and the connecting track to Fort Mason.

North Yard overview

Towards the top of the picture, one track (#2) currently rounds the corner and will shortly connect to the tracks already in operation. #1 track will soon parallel #2. On the right side are the four tracks of North Yard, varying wildly in size. Track capacities are 7 cars, 6, 4 and 3 cars. Such is what fits into the city block grid.

On the left side of this picture will be Pier 43 (the car float) and Pier 43 ½ (additional tracks to support swapping blocks of cars on and off the float).

In this area, new construction consists of a single left-hand crossover, 4 left hand switches, and the longest single piece of straight track that exists on the railroad (about 4 feet).   Add in some other yard tracks of short lengths.

Track repairs

I’ve asked my crews to drop a flag every time that a car or engine derails that’s not obviously the crew’s fault (e.g., running through a switch isn’t interesting). Ideally, they’ll put a note on the flag with the car number and any other relevant information (direction of travel, orientation of car, etc). I provide several different colors of sticky notes (hey, 3M is local, so I use actual Post-it® Notes), and give each crew member a pad.

The switch into Ghirardelli was a notable problem, with about a dozen notes at the end of two sessions. Really, I think every move over the switch didn’t work, as long as the switch was reversed. Normal wasn’t too bad. Definitely trouble with the switch, because the cars listed varied a lot.

It didn’t take too long of careful investigation to determine that the guardrails were missing on that particular switch. Now some people will claim that a switch shouldn’t need the guard rails, and that problems with their absence is a sign of a poor switch. I’m not one of those people. Nothing else about the switch was out of tolerances (handy dandy NMRA gauge to the rescue). Shortly, two new guard rails had been installed and testing proceeded to show happiness.

The third session was held after that repair job, and I’m happy to report that *NO* flags were thrown there at all during the course of the session. And, yes, that track did get used, so I know that there was movement there.

During this last session, few flags were thrown, and they varied more in location. I think each was at a place where at least one other flag has been thrown, and some were the same car at that particular spot. There are a couple of cars that I am still running with crappy wheels. If I can get them to work properly, I think everything else should be fine.

John & Jerry switching North Point

That’s the third op session now. 97 to go before I have to make T-shirts.

More track laying

[ Okay, so it was a long hiatus, for more than just track acquisition.  ]

There is now track feeding into the North Point & Beach Street line.   Along The Embarcadero is the “main line” of the State Belt, two or three tracks with a host of crossovers between the tracks and spurs serving industries and piers all along the route.

Trackwork along The Embarcadero

Trackwork along The Embarcadero

This is enough track to support a runaround, which is needed to operate on the North Point line.    There’s a spur for Fiberboard Products, and several team tracks.  There will soon be a third track (on the right side of the photo) and spurs into several piers.

Train’s a-coming down the track

Customers along North Point are excited about the coming of the railroad.  Now Simmons Mattresses can be loaded into boxcars for shipment throughout the western states.  Cream of Tartar can be shipped from Stauffer Chemical.  And Nash Distributors might finally be able to fill their warehouse space with incoming shipments.

north-beach

 

Okay, we’re still wondering just how useful it will be to load car when we can’t take them beyond the end of the street, since we run out of track at that point.   And just how did that train get here?

But there’s track down on my railroad, with the main street running down North Point and several spurs completed.  The engine is just entering the curve that swings over to the alignment on Beach St.

Obviously there is still track to go down — on the left is the spur to the S.P. auto unloading ramp and Leslie Salt.   In the front is the lead to the Del Monte cannery and a spur to Musto Keenan.

But I ran out of rail, so a brief hiatus in order for the gandy dancers.

The bones are finished

Day 2 of the Last Week of the Year:

I’ve had much of my benchwork in place for a couple of months now (see  this post), but today I finished the base structure for the layout.

Last Sunday I got help to pick up several sheets of Homasote and one more sheet of plywood (thanks, Dave).  Today I picked up several more 1x4s and 1x3s (Menard’s Black Label select pine — nice stuff), and I finished up the last section of L-girders, plus the joists for the subroadbed.  It’s nice how quickly everything goes when you’ve got a plan and all of the tools readily at hand.

IMG_0590

I do need to add some braces between the legs and the girder, but that’s another run to Menard’s (1x2s).

The plywood is in place, the Homasote is all cut and in place.  I’ve even got some temporary fascia installed.

Now to do another solid round of dust cleanup, and I’m ready to start making some progress on something above the benchwork for once.

IMG_0591 IMG_0592

The jig is out

I’m using L-girder benchwork, with fairly large areas of flat ground (since most everything prototypically should be around 15 feet above sea level, if that).   This would normally entail risers with cleats on them, so I can drive all of the screws from below.   The main reason to use L-girder benchwork is the ability to move risers & joists as needed, and that is hard to do if you drive screws in from the top.

I dislike using cleats on the risers — it’s not that hard but it can be kind of fiddly.

I also have the luck of being able to use most of my joists as the riser as well, since most of the lumber I used to make the joists was cut at the same time so they’re the same height.

IMG_0502

Time to dig out the tools.  I have a jig to make these nifty pocket holes, and they work beautifully for driving the screws from below.   This joist is a bit smaller than most, so it’s attached to the leg and not the L-girder.

The jig holds the board securely and has a guide for a special bit.  Everything is set “just right” for the pocket hole to be drilled and a pilot for the screw placement.  A bit of sawdust is created, and you’re ready to drive the screw and hold the joist to the plywood.

IMG_0500

 

I placed several pockets to attach to the boards above.  No part of the screw protrudes above the surface of the plywood when they’re driven.

IMG_0501

 

I think they’ll all be out of the way as I need to drill switch throw holes in order to place the switch motors, but if not, I’ll just move the joist.  That is the beauty of the whole L-girder system after all.

The jig is from Kreg and can be ordered online or from your favorite local hardware store.